But - if you are patient enough, or able to turn a blind eye to this beautiful child’s occasional temper tantrum, you will find there is a great deal of charm to be experienced in Alice: Madness Returns . Read more
Even so, when McGee’s haunting and uncomfortable adaptation comes together harmoniously, Madness Returns' shortcomings fade away and we’re swept up in a concept worthy of praise. Madness Returns will be dissected and judged on its constituent pieces today, but will ultimately remembered for its vision. Read more
Suspension of disbelief is a common term in film, but games require a similar level of immersion to succeed. The best games dunk your head into the waters of their worlds, and don't bring you up to breathe until the credits roll. But when some elements don't work, that suspension shatters and screams: it's just a game. Alice: Madness Returns is an uneven journey of immersion that hits a lot of high points but constantly shows off its cracks. Read more
Every so often, Madness Returns' level layouts displays a glimmer of creativity, such as when playing cards flip and slide into view, extending your path. However, reaching your destination is a usually predictable affair. You spend a lot of time jumping onto floating surfaces and into gusts of air so that you can flip a switch that creates another set of surfaces and gusts. Read more
So it’s a shame that the play is so damn ordinary. It’s disappointing when titles so obviously focus on one element of the experience and hope that it’s enough to hide gaping flaws in the rest of the title, particularly when this sort of world allows for a massive amount of creative freedoms. Read more